Florida woman orders Uber from Olive Garden. Then she changes her pin to pickup at Barnes and Noble—it’s much cheaper

“This kind of stuff will be the downfall of Uber.”
UBer ride (l) woman shares Uber experience (c) Olive Garden entrance (r)
Photo by Viktor Avdeev on Unsplash, @spacecowgirl710_/Tiktok, Brett on adobe stock

A woman waiting for a ride outside an Olive Garden says Uber quoted her $30 to get home. So she moved her pickup pin to the Barnes & Noble on the other side of the same parking lot. The price dropped to $24.

Space Cowgirl (@spacecowgirl710_) recently posted a TikTok about the alleged price discrepancy. Her post has been viewed more than 353,700 times.

‘You Might Just Have To Walk A Few Feet’

“Here’s a trick for y’all when you’re getting an Uber,” she says. “I just put my location to Olive Garden, and it was gonna be $30 for an Uber. So I walked over here to Barnes and Noble, literally right across the street. You can see, same parking lot, and it went down to $24.”

“So, yeah, change your pin around, see what’s cheaper,” she says. “You might just have to walk a few feet.”

In replies to commenters, she explained how she noticed. “I was waiting for the bus, which is right next to Barnes & Noble, and when I switched from the bus stop to Olive Garden, I was like, ‘Wait a damn minute,’” she wrote. When a viewer suggested the price had simply changed over time, she replied: “I didn’t actually move at first, just moved the pins around on my phone, so it’s literally seconds apart.”

She also said it was a Friday evening, and that she usually takes the bus there and gets an Uber home “if the bus isn’t running.”

Why A Few Hundred Feet Can Change The Fare

Uber says its upfront prices are based on “the estimated trip time and distance from origin to destination, as well as demand patterns for that route at that time.” On top of that sits surge pricing, which the company says “automatically goes into effect when there are more riders in a given area than available drivers.” According to Uber’s surge pricing page, the algorithm reacts to supply and demand “at a hyperlocal level, meaning high demand in one area of a city doesn’t impact prices in another,” and “prices update frequently.”

Researchers have tested the walk-across-the-line idea before. In a 2015 study, computer scientists at Northeastern University ran 43 simulated Uber clients in San Francisco and Manhattan for four weeks. They found that Uber had divided cities into “surge areas” with separate prices, that “the majority of surges last less than five minutes,” and that riders near Times Square could have booked a cheaper UberX “10-20% of the time” by walking into a neighboring area. The authors warned that “users may receive dramatically different prices due to small changes in geolocation.” Uber has since moved to upfront fares, so the study describes an older version of the system.

Drivers in the comments described the same mechanism. “When we see surge pricing, it looks like a cloud over certain parts of the city in purple,” wrote pmiosss, who said they drive for Uber. “Sometimes that cloud is tiny; sometimes that cloud is over a majority of the city.” Jsntodd, who said they worked in Uber customer support for about a year and a half, wrote that “the biggest one is just the available capacity of drivers vs riders.”

‘Walk To The Other Side Of Barnes And Noble’

The top comment, with more than 12,400 likes, came from flips4bracelets: “Walk to the other side of Barnes and Noble and keep checking the price until you walk home.” Space Cowgirl replied with two laughing emojis.

Plenty of viewers said they’d done the same. “I discovered this glitch last year. Medium city regional airport (6 gates). Uber home 15 miles is $50. I walk about 1 mile to the nearest business plaza, Uber home $15,” wrote user255459876. “I left a club in Vegas, walked across the street to a fast food place, went from $60 to $12!” wrote evajohns.

Others had theories that are harder to pin down. “Rumor has it they even charge people more if they know the phone’s battery is low,” wrote xplore.la. That rumor goes back to 2016, when Keith Chen, then Uber’s head of economic research, told an NPR podcast that riders with nearly dead phones were more willing to accept surge prices. Chen “stressed the company is not going to act on the information to set fares,” CBC News reported.

Some viewers saw a problem for the company. “This kind of stuff will be the downfall of Uber,” wrote deepeningauthor. Rosierinthepool, writing as a driver, asked riders who move their pin to “flag your driver down and stand in a spot where you are easily seen. Our apps can get funky when this is done, and we end up driving around looking crazy.”

When one viewer told her to keep walking and the ride would be free, Space Cowgirl replied: “True, but not worth my life.”

Subplot News reached out to Space Cowgirl via TikTok direct message and to Uber via email for comment. We’ll be sure to update this if they respond.

Toyota steering wheel (l) woman shares oil change experience (c) car oil change (r)

‘You have the newer Toyota’: Woman goes to dealership for oil change. Then a worker refuses because she’s only gone 5,000 miles

Prev
candy crush app (l) woman shares waitress experience (c) woman playing a game on her iPad (r)

Las Vegas server plays Candy Crush on her iPad when famous customer walks in. Then she reveals why: ‘Um… hello?’

Next