A physical credit card is something that some customers use daily, taking it in and out of their wallets and tapping or inserting it into payment devices. As such, they expect it to be sturdy and withstand a good amount of wear.
According to one American Express customer, however, after just six months of use, her Amex Platinum card is falling apart.
In a clip with over 1.9 million views, TikTok creator Raenah (@raenahmarie) films her hand holding an American Express card with a floral Kehinde Wiley design.
As she twists it to the side, she pulls the two layers apart, showing that they have started to detach at the edge.
“I just feel like a $900/year credit card shouldn’t do this on the reg??” she wrote in the video’s text overlay.
In the caption, she asked her viewers whether they had experienced something similar.
“Anyone else’s amex platinum fully fall apart every like 6 months or just me??” she wrote, also tagging American Express’s official TikTok account.
Have other American Express cardholders experienced something similar?
Several other customers online have complained about American Express credit cards that are allegedly falling apart.
One Reddit user on r/amex said they had recently received a replacement Platinum Card “due to [their] previous one separating front & back.”
“Not the first time and has happened and IMO has happened way too often,” they wrote.
Another Reddit user on the same subreddit posted a photo of their Amex card splitting in two, just like the TikToker showed in her video.
“How did this even happen?” they wrote. “Sure, I had the rose gold for years but still.”
A More With Miles writer also described a similar experience with American Express’s metal cards in a blog post on the site.
According to them, there’s a layer of plastic between the two metal sides, and the glue deteriorates over time. They say they’ve experienced it several times.
However, they pointed out that ordering a new card is free, and consumers can do that through the bank’s app.
Viewers can’t get over the yearly fees
Some viewers pointed out that Raenah could order a new card for free.
“Oh, I do every time but may just give up this card for annoyance factor,” she responded.
Many others were surprised by how high the yearly fee is.
“You pay 900 a year for a credit card company to charge you interest? that’s wild,” one commenter wrote.
“I feel like paying 900 a year for a card is the main issue here,” another said.
“How good of benefits does that get you?” one asked. “I’m big on credit card rewards but I’ve never in my life paid them.”
“Do you travel, shop, eat out a lot? If so it pays itself off easily. If not it’s not worth it. Credit cards are not a flex,” a commenter replied. “Anyone with halfway decent credit can get a platinum.”
@raenahmarie
Subplot News has reached out to American Express and Raenah via email for comment.


