New York woman goes to Baskin-Robbins with a coupon for a free birthday scoop. Then a worker claims they don’t have any ice cream: ‘Gaslight Robbins’

‘What do you mean the ice cream I’m looking at doesn’t exist?’
woman shares Baskin Robbins experience (l) Baskin Robbins ice cream cone (r)

A woman who posts as @ksnap199 in New York City says she walked into her neighborhood Dunkin’-Baskin-Robbins to cash in a free birthday scoop days before it expired and got turned away from a case full of ice cream.

‘There Was 12 Options’

She’d been to this location plenty of times, she says—”if you know what I mean.” No one else was inside. She pulled up the free scoop coupon, and the woman at the counter answered before she’d picked a flavor. “We don’t have any ice cream,” the TikToker reports her saying.

She looked down. A dozen tubs, full or half-full, sat in the case by her count. She assumed a mix-up and asked again, just the small scoop. Same line.

“Oh, what about the ice cream right here?” she asked, per her account. “We’re all out.” The tubs looked full. Was something wrong with it? Was it bad? No, the worker said. No delivery yet. We’ve been out for two days.

A second employee came up from the back, she said. She tried again: Can I get some ice cream? “We don’t have any. We’re waiting on the delivery,” she reports the worker responding. She pointed at the vanilla a foot away. Same answer.

By then, she felt like a “fat” person “ready to start a war over a scoop.” So, she said, “Perfect, great,” and walked home in silence. She didn’t photograph the case. If she looked at a picture of twelve full tubs tomorrow, she said, she’d need a hospital.

“So you win, Baskin Robbins. Thank you for this experience.”

Let’s see what the people had to say.

‘I Scream. You Scream. We All Scream Because We’re in Psychosis’

“This is so … funny, though. Imagine they were so bored they were like, ‘Next person that walks in, we are just going to see if we can convince them we don’t have any ice cream,'” one person said.

Another person joked, using a popular novelty song, “I scream. You scream. We all scream because we’re in psychosis.”

One commenter, delving into a new level of pettiness, wrote, “Go behind the counter and start scooping the ice cream yourself, and when [they ask] you, be like, ‘What ice cream?'”

The Ice Cream Machine’s Always Broken

There’s no restaurant more perpetually known for its epic gaslighting of customers than good ol’ McDonald’s. No chain has made more “you can’t have the ice cream” folklore, with its soft-serve dispensers that go down so often that they’ve become an easy joke.

In 2021, the FTC finally decided to do something about it and pressed franchisees on the ice cream failures; McDonald’s said it had “no reason to believe we are the focus of an FTC investigation.”

The chain couldn’t (or wouldn’t) fix it, so others did. In 2024, the Copyright Office cleared third parties to repair the machines, a win Public Knowledge’s Meredith Rose called one with “nothing vanilla” about it. Customers had already built their own receipts: software engineer Rashiq Zahid reverse-engineered McDonald’s ordering app to map every broken machine in the country.

Subplot News reached out to @ksnap199 via TikTok comment and direct message and to Baskin-Robbins via email. We will update this story if they respond.

@chantelmay5/Tiktok Photo by Viktor Avdeev on Unsplash

Woman flies into popular Texas airport. Then she sees what it takes to get an Uber

Prev
Mercedes car logo (l) woman shares car dealership issues (c) Porsche car logo (r)

Woman trades her Mercedes for a Porsche. Then she gets a troubling call from the dealership: ‘UPS must have lost it’

Next